Historic Inventory Survey

The Sturbridge Historic Resources Inventory was commissioned by the Town of Sturbridge, administered by the Sturbridge Historical Commission (SHC), prepared by the Pioneer Valley Planning Commission (PVPC) throughout 2016 and 2017, and supported by Sturbridge Community Preservation Act funds. The "Historic Resources Inventory Final Report" report discusses the methodology, results, and final recommendations of the four-phase project, which took place during 2016 and 2017.

In 2018 The Sturbridge Historic Resources Inventory was prepared by the Public Archaeology Laborartory (PAL). "The Final Report Sturbridge Community-wide Historic Properties Survey Update Phase II" discusses results of this phase.

The following list was narrowed to the most significant resources using the following criteria:

  • Historic buildings that are potentially threatened, including some which were previously inventoried;
  • Historic buildings which appear to be eligible for the National Register, either individually or related within a district;
  • Historic buildings with special significance to Sturbridge; and/or
  • Architecturally distinguished historic buildings, or those that are an excellent example of style, with moderate to good integrity.

The preliminary list was evaluated and finalized by the Sturbridge Historical Commission and field work commenced in the Spring of 2017.

 Historic Area Inventory

Historic Name
Bay Path Motel Area
Fiskdale Mill Area
Haynes Corner Area
Hyland Orchard Area
Orchard Inn Area
Publick House Area
Sturbridge Town Common

Wight Motel Area

Wight-Snell Manufacturing Area

The Wocester South Agricultural Society Exhibition Hall

 

Historic Building Inventory

Following is an inventory of some of the historic homes and buildings in the Town of Sturbridge.  Further information on each property can be accessed by clicking on the "Historic Name." This is just a sample of historic structures in Sturbridge. For a complete list or more information about Massachusetts Cultural Resources, please visit the MACRIS site. 

View the Historic Building Inventory in the GIS StoryMap here.

Street

Number

Street NameHistoric NameYearStyle
26Allen RoadJoel & Martha Plimpton Houseca. 1786Cape form
3Auger Street

Increase and Lucinda Sykes House

ca. 1855no style
11Auger StreetHeck Residenceca. 1850Late Federal
8Bates Hill

Simeon A. and Mary Drake House

1836Federal
10Bates Hill

Truman and Mary Charles Rental House

ca. 1780Cape form
17Bennetts RoadThomas Gray Cottage1930Craftsman
51Bennetts Road

Eunice Maloney Cottage

1935front-gabeled cottage
2Brookfield Road

Mrs. L. Cartier Two-family House

ca. 1855no style
8Brookfield RoadFire Station1922Modern
29Brookfield Road

La Flammes’ Market

1939no style
55Brookfield RoadPatrick and Mary Jarret House1878-1892Queen Anne
60Brookfield RoadEliab and Fanny Marsh Houseca. 1814Federal
142Brookfield RoadJoseph Marsh Houseca. 1760Georgian
213Brookfield RoadEliab and Fanny Marsh Houseca. 1975Georgian to Federal
231Brookfield RoadJonathan Philips Curtis Farmca. 1804Cape altered to Ranch
249Brookfield Road

George Griswold Speculation House

ca. 1913Craftsman
285Brookfield Road

Cyrus and Bathsheba Fay House

1784-1795Cape form
6Cedar StreetSturbridge Veterinary Hospital1966Modern
83Cedar StreetThomas Marsh Farm Buildingca. 1860no style
2-8Chamberlain AvenueJared Lamb Building1815-1825Federal
10 Chamberlain AvenueSimeon Allen Houseca. 1820Greek Revival
12Chamberlain AvenueAllen-Bachellor Houseca. 1800Federal
12Champeaux

Eli and Mary Marsh House

ca. 1762Georgian
4Charlton StreetJames Bachellor House1836Greek Revival
5Charlton StreetJared Lamb Houseca. 1821Greek Revival
6Charlton StreetAlvan Bond House and Gifford Barnca. 1821Greek Revival
9Charlton StreetMerrick House and Cooper Barn1815-1825Federal
10Charlton StreetGeorge Davis House and Barnca. 1812Greek Revival
13Charlton StreetDrew Corey Bullock Place1929Dutch Colonial
14Charlton StreetRockwood House1935N/A
16Charlton StreetOtis Warner Shopca. 1835No Style
17 Charlton StreetRoswell Warner House and Barn1815-1820Federal
18Charlton StreetLewis Pelton Houseca. 1834Greek Revival
20Charlton StreetAlbert Freeman House1918-1925No Style
3-5Church StreetFiskdale Mills Worker Housing1870-1898No Style
3Church StreetBoudreau House1873Greek Revival
5Church StreetMill Worker Housing1873Greek Revival
7Church StreetKirby Estate1873Greek Revival
16Church StreetSt. Anne's Church & Shrine1883Italian Gothic
16Church StreetSt. Anne's Rectory1887N/A
20Church StreetSt. Patrick's Church1883Victorian
20Church StreetSt. Anne's PavillionN/AN/A
20Church StreetSt. Anne's Outdoor ShrineN/AN/A
14Douty Road

C. G. Allen Farm

late 1700s -

early 1800s

Georgian
26Farquhar RoadWilliam R. Farquhar/W. and M. Edwards Houseca. 1944Colonial Revival
47Farquhar RoadSamuel, Jr. and Mary Morse Houseca. 1800Georgian
77Farquhar RoadJames and Elizabeth Belknap Houseca. 1864Raised Cape
8Fiske Hill RoadOtis E. Leach Houseby 1931Classical Revival
12Fiske Hill RoadHarry H. Pickles Housepre 1931Classiscal Revival
15Fiske Hill Road

Walter L. Fish, Jr. House

before 1944Greek or Classical Revival
24Fiske Hill RoadWestwell Residenceca. 1815-1817Federal
55Fiske Hill Road

Harry G. Estabrook House

ca. 1940Colonial Revival
60Fiske Hill RoadRaymond M. Burnham House1922-1930Colonial Revival
66Fiske Hill RoadDavid Fiske House1786Federal with alterations
71Fiske Hill RoadFirst Well on Fiske Hill1730'sPlaque/Memorial
77Fiske Hill Road

Daniel Fiske III/Channing M. Wells House

1832, 1937Federal to Colonial
85Fiske Hill RoadDaniel Fiske II Houseca. 1811

Colonial (Georgian) with alterations

96Fiske Hill RoadPlaque in Memory of Fiske Hill School1949Plaque/Memorial
108Fiske Hill RoadFiske-Matys ResidenceEarly 1800sModern
120Fiske Hill RoadCapt. Simeon Fiske/Simeon F. Marsh Houseca. 1804

Georgian with alterations

205Fiske Hill RoadEbenezar Cutting/Edward Nichols House and Barn1812Georgian with alterations
23Hall RoadSamuel and Lucy Hobbs Houseca. 1775Georgian
1Haynes StreetDaniel Plimpton Houseca. 1800Utilitarian
3Haynes StreetHaynes Family House1830-1850Greek Revival
3Haynes StreetBarn1935Gambrel
Haynes StreetDeacon Dunton Houseca. 1780Federal
12Haynes StreetOrchard Inn Area1964 - 1970Modern
2-6High StreetFiskdale Mills Worker Duplex1870-1894No Style
21High StreetPeloquin to Zuiss to Chicoine1873Greek Revival
14Hinman StreetBates-Thorpe House1880-1890Late Victorian
9Holland RoadFiskdale Upper Mill1865, 1869, 1875-1921, 1933-1952, 1975No Style
100Holland RoadGeorge and Mary Eliza Holmes Houseca. 1850No style
220Holland Road

Abijah and Ruth Shumway House

ca. 1880Federal
222Holland RoadDistrict #4 Schoolhouseca. 1855Uilitarian
224Holland Road

Nathan Cheney and Elijah Plimpton House

ca. 1793Federal
12Main Street

Norval and Anna Newell House

ca. 1869raised Cape
60Main Street

Arthur and Eileen Atwood House

1946Minimal Traditional
70Main StreetEugene Gabree Investment Houseca. 1919Colonial Revival
75Main StreetAndre and Lillian Pinel House1941Minimal Traditional
82Main StreetJohn and Eva Ryan House1925Craftsman
171Main StreetSylvanus W. Stone Houseca. 1855no style
204Main Street

Alfred and Ettienette Berthiaume House

1937Tudor Revival
258Main StreetSturbridge Professional Center1970Neo-Federal
260Main StreetDr. Jacob Corey House1805-1815Federal
262Main StreetDeacon George Davis House1815-1825Federal
265Main StreetEast Schoolhouseca. 1832Federal
266Main StreetRoswell Warner House and Barnca. 1800Federal
267Main StreetNo Name1829-1844No Style
269Main StreetJohn and Sally Paine Houseca. 1805Federal and Greek Revival
271Main StreetFayette A. Eldridge House1918No Style
272Main StreetBenjamin D. Hyde Houseca. 1843Gothic Revival
274Main StreetJohn Coburn Houseca. 1783Federal
275Main StreetChamberlain House1918Colonial Revival
277Main StreetPublick House Area1772, 1870, 1904-1911, 1938, 1965, 1971-1977, 2010, 2017Federal, Colonial Revival
277Main StreetPublick House1772Colonial
283Main StreetWheelock-Champion-Bachellor Houseca. 1820-1857Greek Revival
293Main StreetOld Burial Ground1750Cemetery
301Main StreetSturbridge Center School1855Greek Revival
306Main StreetJoshua Hyde Public Library1896Colonial Revival
308Main StreetSturbridge Town Hall1836, 1858, 1910Greek Revival, Colonial Revival

310

Main StreetOliver B. Wight Houseca. 1832

Greek Revival

320Main StreetCandy & Gift Shopca. 1955New-Greek Revival
331Main StreetSouthbridge and Sturbridge Street Railway Substationca. 1898Colonial Revival
366Main StreetBrimfield Congrestional Church Conference Hallca. 1820Gree Revival
407Main StreetGeorge E. Richards House and Barnca. 1874Italianate
408Main StreetJ. Dwight Underwood Houseca. 1884Queen Anne
413Main StreetGeorge E. Richards Rental Houseca. 1886Italianate
454Main StreetLivingston Shumway Houseca. 1846Greek Revival
468Main StreetMartin L. Phillips House and Barnca. 1900Queen Anne
473Main StreetJohn and Lizzie Hooker House and Barnca. 1887Queen Anne
480Main Street

Snellville District #2 Schoolhouse

1874Italianate
484Main StreetJabez Westgate House and Barnca. 1840Greek Revival
501Main StreetMoses and Lucy Morris House; Pink Haven Motel1830-1831, 1950, 1959No Style
502Main StreetEmory L. Bates House and Barnca. 1855Greek Revival
504Main StreetDavid and Rebecca Atherton Houseca. 1842Greek Revival
507Main StreetSturbridge Second Adventist Churchca. 1892No Style
509Main StreetHiram and Seraph Hayward Houseca. 1846Greek Revival
511Main StreetHiram and Seraph Hayward Houseca. 1846Greek Revival
514Main StreetTruman Charles Houseca. 1841Greek Revival
518Main StreetFiskdale Baptist Church Vestry1857-1870Greek Revival
524Main StreetHoratio N. Drake Houseca. 1835Greek Revival
531Main StreetFiskdale Mill Blacksmith Shop1857-1870No Style
538Main StreetFiskdale Housepre-1857Greek Revival
544Main StreetLemuel Lumbard Building1836-1857Greek Revival
546Main StreetTimothy Maloney Tenement1878-1898Queen Anne
548Main StreetWheaton Knight House1857-1870Italianate
552Main StreetJosiah J. Fiske Buildingca. 1825Greek Revival
572Main Street

Commercial Block "Blackington Building"

ca. 1874-1880Gothic Revival
8Maple StreetFederated Church of Sturbridge and Fiskdale1910, 1954, 1960sColonial Revival
9Maple StreetThomas Lyon/J.E. Purdy House

circa 1835-1845

Possibly Greek Revival/Altered
10Maple StreetCongregational Parsonageby 1869

Greek Revival with Italianate details

14Maple StreetChester H. Walker Houseprior to 1870Greek Revival with Italianate details
17Maple StreetBenjamin C. Weld House and Barnca. 1850Greek Revival
5Mashapaug Road

Penuel Plimpton House/Pine Grove Farm

1787 and later alterations

Georgian/Folk Victorian

104McGilpin Road

Ezekiel Robbins House

Probably 1826, by 1857Federal
138McGilpin RoadJohn Smith Houseby 1857Federal with additions
14McGregory Road

Nelson J. Fay and Roberta M. Fay House

1755 (NH); 1947; ca. 1968

Colonial with alterations

340New Boston RoadHyde Family Houseby 1857Altered
3Old Stagecoach Road

Abner Allen House

between 1735 and 1772Colonial
68Paradise LaneAlva L. Burroughs House

Early to mid-20th century

Colonial Revival
13Podunk Road

George J. and Delina D. Cloutier House

1912 (barn), ca. 1946 (house)

Colonial Revival (Stylized Ranch)
177Podunk RoadNichols Family House and Davis Family Barn

Prior to 1851

Colonial with later alterations

251Podunk RoadJonas Bemis/Silverberg Family Farmby mid-19th century with later alterationsColonial with later alterations
531Route 15Samuel Thompson House

possibly by 1857 to end of 19th century

Altered
8School StreetFiskdale School

Italianate, altered

1896
210Shepard Road

Hamilton Woolen Co. House and Barn

Georgian1805
44Streeter RoadLemuel L. Holmes/Frederick Holmes House1835, with later alterationsheavily altered
11Summit Avenue

Fiskdale Mills Agent’s Residence

Between 1870-1898

Queen Anne
16Summit Avenue

Fiskdale Mills Co. Farm House

Early to late 19th century

Altered
24Taft StreetIsaac Child Jr. Houseca. 1792Federal
99Wallace RoadHamilton Woolen Co. House

Prior to 1857

Georgian
116Wallace RoadPlimpton FarmPrior to 1857Altered
10Whittemore Road

Rice-Simpson Barn/Gladding House

c. 1792; mid-to-late 20th century alterations

Altered
35Willard Road

Hiram Rice House

by 1857Altered